What is the difference between ishmael and isaac




















This is the well of Zam Zam and their ordeal is commemorated in the Hajj rituals Muslims perform today. The Quran tells us that Ishmael was a Prophet and a Messenger. Isaac is considered a Prophet of God in all three Abrahamic faiths. Muslims respect and honor Prophet Isaac, as they do all the Prophets of God. The Quran mentions Isaac more than 10 times but does not give details of his life. Islamic scholars however agree with the many biblical traditions that tell us that Isaac was a spiritual man concerned about his progeny; he was anxious that his feuding sons Jacob and Esau end their conflict and live in a way sanctioned by God.

Muslims believe in the Biblical stories only when they do not contradict or go against the Quran or the authentic traditions of Prophet Muhammad. From the beginning of Islamic history, there has been scholarly debate about the name of the child to be sacrificed by Prophet Abraham.

It is interesting to note that the Quran does not mention a name as if to remind us that the name of the child is not the most important matter. What is important is what we learn from the narrative. Bmp converter. Pdf converter. Rtf converter. Csv converter. Word converter. Doc converter. Docx converter. Html converter. Odp converter. Odt converter. Ods converter. Ppt converter. Pptx converter.

Ps converter. Txt converter. Xlsx converter. Xls converter. Xml converter. Length converter. Weight converter. Temperature converter. Energy converter. Area converter. Epub converter. Mobi converter. Azw3 converter.

Mp4 converter. Webm converter. Flv converter. Mkv converter. Avi converter. Mov converter. Wmv converter. Android video converter. Iphone video converter. Ipad video converter. Mobile video converter. Xbox video converter. Psp video converter. Kindle video converter. Mp3 converter. Wma converter. Wav converter. Flac converter.

M4a converter. Alac converter. Amr converter. Ogg converter. Aiff converter. Aac converter. Android audio converter. Iphone audio converter. Ipad audio converter. Ipod audio converter. In terms of this article, the exception of course concerns Ishmael.

Surah 37 details the birth and near sacrifice of Ishmael by Abraham, while surah 2 5 speaks to the building of the Kaaba - the edifice located in Mecca Makka that represents the absolute centre of the Islamic faith. Ishmael's birth is narrated in verse of surah Prior to this, in verses , Abraham is depicted as "contending" with pagans who worshipped idols and the stars. Abraham destroyed their pagan idols, for which the pagans rose up against him, but God "brought them that is, the pagans low" Surah and Abraham then sought refuge in God.

Abraham prays: "My Lord grant me a doer of good deeds" Surah and his faith in the one God is rewarded, for God speaks, saying: "So We gave him the good news of a forbearing son" Surah The forbearing son is Ishmael by implication - he is not named in the text. Verses then put us on what appears to be familiar ground: God reveals to Abraham in a dream that he, Abraham, must offer his son - his only son - in sacrifice - except, of course, the son referred to is Ishmael -because, as will be noted later, in Islamic tradition, Isaac is not yet born.

In verse , Abraham tells Ishmael his dream, and Ishmael offers his peaceful acquiescence in verse , saying: "O my father, do as thou art commanded; if Allah please, thou wilt find me patient. Paralleling the biblical account, Abraham and Ishmael are both prepared for the ultimate moment when, dramatically, God intervenes, and a surrogate, a ram caught in a thicket, becomes the sacrifice.

As reward for his obedience, it is revealed to Abraham in verse that he will have another son, Isaac. It is clear from this surah that Ishmael had to be the son to be sacrificed, as Isaac's birth was only promised following this test of Abraham's faith. Instead of presenting him as a significant figure, the Genesis view of the man, while still respecting him as a son of Abraham, places him on a far lower plane than his younger brother Isaac.

While there is a possibility of course that this marginalising of Ishmael in favour of Isaac has to do with Hagar's social position - servant and as noted earlier, this is the Jewish and Christian view - there are grounds for disputing this assertion, as will be shown. Genesis tells us that, when Abram was seventy years old, God instructed him to leave Haran, located in the foothills of the Anatolian plateau of modern Turkey, to go to "the land I will show you Some eleven years pass, and Abram cries out to the Lord that, far from making him a great nation, he remains childless and not only that, in a culture where, it seems, women could not inherit meaning Sarai could not come into Abram's estate , then Abram's servant, Eliezer of Damascus - if we read Genesis , 3 correctly the phrase is enigmatic; Wenham - will be his heir.

Sarai, seeing the distress that her barrenness has created for her husband, has an idea. She will give her maidservant Hagar the Egyptian to him. It is important to note, in this instance, that she says as "wife" Heb. These words are significant.

The implication is that Sarai will consider a child born to a surrogate - in this instance, Hagar - and sired by Abram, as her own child. Such a solution appears to have been a typical social custom of the time. Brenneman writes: "Hagar was a surrogate mother whom Sarah was obliged by law to give to Abraham to provide an heir".

It has to be said that Sarah waited a very long time she was 76 years old before acquiescing to what was either law or, more likely, established tradition. On reflection, this is a little strange, for who is to say at this juncture that this child, a son, from Hagar is not God's way of fulfilling His promise to Abram?

Regardless, Sarai sends Hagar away into the wilderness. There Hagar encounters an angel of the Lord who encourages her to return to Sarai and submit to her. The angel further says that Hagar's offspring will be multiplied "that they cannot be counted for multitude" Gen. Hagar returns to Sarai and submits to her. The child is born. He is called Ishmael, "the Lord has listened". The Bible tells us that he is so named because the Lord has listened to Hagar's complaint - "for the Lord has given ear to your affliction" Gen.

But Abram names the child Gen. In doing so, is he not acknowledging perhaps that God has listened to his earlier plea for a child in Genesis , and God's response in Genesis b-6? He asked God for a son, and now he has one. The Bible is silent on Ishmael's legitimacy; that is to say, his legitimacy is not questioned, which may be because Ishmael's position as son and heir is a given fact arising out of accepted local custom see note 7 above.

This idea is reinforced by the later narratives regarding surrogate motherhood that began with Sarai. Rachel, Jacob's barren wife, invited her husband to "go into" her servant Bilhah, so that she, Bilhah, as Rachel says, "can bear upon my knees and that I too may have children through her", Gen. Jacob complies and ends up with two sons by Bilhah - Dan and Naphtali Gen. We might even consider mothers who have become barren in the natural course of things: Jacob's other wife, Leah, having ceased childbearing, celebrates the birth of children Gad and Asher by Jacob to her servant Zilpah Gen.

Note that, inclusive of Ishmael, no issues of adoption or legitimacy are mentioned in any of the narratives just cited; indeed, absent any commentary to the contrary, the many children born to handmaids and servants appear to be happily absorbed into the various family circles. While some jealousy is evident, especially on the part of Rachel Gen. In fact, it is whom the father is that determines legitimacy and birth rights: Deuteronomy explicitly prohibits the disenfranchising of the first-born son - regardless of the mother's status - and further provides that he shall receive a double portion of his father's inheritance.

While Deuteronomy is generally considered a later contribution to the Pentateuch see 5. Abraham then asks if Ishmael might also be blessed: "O that Ishmael might live in your sight! God replies: "As for Ishmael, I have heard you", and goes on to say that Ishmael shall father twelve nesi'im the word means "elevated ones", or important persons; most translations read "princes" and become a great nation Gen.

No reason for Ishmael, as first-born son, being sidelined or usurped is provided at this point. If he has sinned against God or Abram and is thus worthy of demotion, we are not told. Notice again that God's promise is that Isaac will father kings, and Ishmael, princes, a clear statement of the intended future superiority of Isaac over his brother.

Nevertheless, it is fourteen years before God's promise to Abraham is fulfilled. Fourteen years during which it seemed entirely reasonable that Ishmael, as first-born, would be the heir of Abraham. One can only imagine the bond that would have developed between them. According to Wenham , Abraham had a "strong paternal affection and particularly [a] deep love for Ishmael". But then, as promised, came Isaac. The day Isaac was weaned, Abraham made a great feast, during the course of which Sarah sees Ishmael "laughing" Gen.

She entreats Abraham to "drive them off", 13 something he is not willing to do: "The matter was very distressing to Abraham on account of his son" Gen.

God adds that, although Abraham's inheritance will be through Isaac, Ishmael too will become a great nation Gen. It is evident that, while Ishmael is to be eclipsed by Isaac, he will not be entirely forgotten, becoming as it were the moon to Isaac's sun.

But, no reason for demoting Ishmael is provided. Against the desires of his heart, but in light of God's assurances regarding Ishmael, Abraham reluctantly complies. James ESV. God still had a plan for both Ishmael and Isaac. But because Abraham in the Bible chose to disobey God, Abraham's sons reaped the consequences.

Drama ensued in their family and tore them apart. Abraham's sons show us that we must trust in God's promises and not try to force them on our own. This article is part of our People of Christianity catalog that features the stories, meaning, and significance of well-known people from the Bible and history. Here are some of the most popular articles for knowing important figures in Christianity:.

How Did the Apostle Paul Die? Who are the Nicolaitans in Revelation? Who Was Deborah in the Bible? Who Was Moses in the Bible?



0コメント

  • 1000 / 1000